Monday, May 21, 2012

"怪誕黑家族" 裡的催眠



Tim Burton+ Johnny Depp合作廿幾年,從無失手。由"Edward Scissorhand"到"無頭谷",到現在重拍英國7080年代怪雞電視劇的怪誕黑家族,這類假驚慄片--少少血腥,多多笑料戲謔和動作場面的方程式已手法嫺熟。

作為消磨時間之作,這片尚算合格,但對於催眠治療師這個行業,則是一個要掃除的新障礙。片中經常出現和現實不符的催眠場面,令不知就裡的觀眾信以為真;令原本要花上相當時間去消除對催眠誤解工作更艱巨。

澄清要點: 

首先,片中Barnabas三兩下功夫就把大宅工人控制等不盡不實。在催眠狀態時,個案仍保時清醒,不會被洗腦,他們可選擇接受那些暗示和訊息。

其次,在催眠過程中,令個案鬆弛是必需階段而且過程較長,我們治療師較少用陀錶導入催眠狀態,因不能確定個案的催眠層次是否夠深入,之後又要用深化來補足,費時失事,催眠層次是否達標,直接影響治療成效。

做戲咁做,咪當真! 

Dr Hoffman 未經Barnabas同意下強行催眠迫供,爆出他是僵屍更是離譜,令很多願意嘗試催眠療法的人卻步。在現實裡,接受治療時,你對自己的意志頭腦完全控制,對於你抗拒的問題或建議,你內心當然不舒服甚至會醒過來。所以Barnabas如羊牯般被人長時間審問後和盤托出,純屬虛構。

小弟亦明白在原裝電視劇裡,常常出現催眠情節以推進劇情,當年看過的人應不會上當。本電影亦保留這敍事手法,但隨着這片全球公映,尤其於對催眠治療欠缺基本認識的國家上映時,是令致力建立專業形象的治療師是很洩氣。

這套電影,消閒無任歡迎,但千萬不能當真,但對於在亞洲,特別是在香港執業的治療師,會加添他們擴闊客路的困難及令市民無法明白催眠無副作用的益處。






Dark Shadows and Hypnotherapy


Tim Burton+ Johnny Depp never fail me , since  Edward Scissorhands to Sleepy Hollow to this campy remake of Dark Shadows- The duo keep churning out what they do best- a huge combination of humor, satire, action all under a pretense of a thriller.

But Dark Shadows has gotten my goat this time- the hypnosis scenes  sprinkled throughout the movie have the potential of reinforcing the misconceptions on my profession-not good especially I am spending considerable time explaining what Hypnosis is NOT.

DEBUNKING : 

First , contrast to what you seen in the movies , YOU DO NOT LOSE CONTROL OF YOURSELF while in session, in fact, one still has the ability to decide what kind of messages to receive and the suggestions which they are advised to act upon.


Second, in a hypnotherapy session, it takes MUCH LONGER FOR CLIENTS TO ENTER HYPNOTIC STATE, because relaxation and induction is absolutely necessary to bring upon hypnosis. Swinging a watch , while quick , is not the usual method we employ or prefer as the clients are not hypnotized deep enough to carry any meaningful work.

The screen in which Helena Bonham Carter essentially interrogated Johnny Depp while the latter was hypnotized. Again, this does not happen in real life, you never surrender your own will and consciousness while in session , instead you will repel on the questions asked and woke up . So Johnny confessed for hours and hours has no connection to reality.

 Don't take it seriously , Please ! 

The original UK series has hypnosis as a vehicle to bring forth plot developments while never claimed to be an accurate representation of real situations. This movie adaptation preserves such a device, but having reached a much wider audience, especially to countries where the understanding of hypnosis or hypnotherapy is NON EXISTENT, only adds to my challenge to dispel any of that garbage mentioned in that movie.


As an audience, I enjoyed the movie as a Friday Evening should; but as a hypnotherapist practicing in Asia, even in Hong Kong, I see as an obstacle to my professional development.